Complaint 28 of 43
Plugin ratings cannot be trusted
$50 or $100 is what one company asked plugin authors to pay for five-star ratings, the WordPress plugin team reported in 2019. In 2022 the same team called fake reviews "a huge problem".
The short answer: The Hostless Duck library has no star ratings to game: each item shows whether it passed testing, on which platforms, and what it does not do yet.
The figures
- $50 or $100
is what one company emailed plugin authors to ask for five-star ratings on WordPress.org, as the plugin team reported in 2019
Make WordPress Plugins
Each figure was read at its source on 21 November 2026. They are other people's measurements, not ours.
The pain
The team that runs the plugin directory has itself written that fake reviews are a huge problem.
Who feels it most: Anyone choosing a plugin.
a huge problem
Why it happens
- Fake reviews are a problem "not just on WordPress.org", the team writes, and they are one there. Source: Make WordPress Plugins
- The team looks for tells: how old the account is, where it signs in from, and how its reviews compare with others posted around the same time. It says there is no single dead giveaway. Source: Make WordPress Plugins
- A review given in return for a discount counts as bought, in the team's own example. Source: Make WordPress Plugins
What it costs
- What was being sold was five-star ratings: the signal an owner reads when choosing a plugin. Source: Make WordPress Plugins
- The honest author pays too. Reviews are removed, and a valid one removed by mistake is in most cases not restored. Source: Make WordPress Plugins
- A plugin whose author keeps doing it is closed. Source: Make WordPress Plugins
How Hostless Duck is built differently
The library has no star ratings to game. Each item shows whether it has passed testing, on which platforms, and what it does not do yet.
Sources
| Source | What kind | Last read |
|---|---|---|
| Make WordPress Plugins: "What's The Deal with Invalid Reviews?" (15 Jun 2022) | Primary | 21 November 2026 |
| Make WordPress Plugins: "Don't Get Scammed" (22 Feb 2019) | Primary | 21 November 2026 |
Found a link that no longer says what we say it does? That is a fault in this page, and we would rather fix it than defend it.
The other articles
Does your site have this one?
Give us your site's address and we read its public pages once: its theme, its plugins, and what Hostless Duck has for each. A real scan of your public pages, never a made-up result. No card.

